Business Car Rental

Automatic or Manual Rental Car: Which Should You Choose?

September 21, 2026

Automatic or manual rental car? It may not be the first thing you think about when booking a car, but your choice can make a real difference once you are on the road. An automatic means less work behind the wheel, while a manual may feel more familiar if that is what you normally drive. In this guide, we compare the differences and help you decide which option suits your trip.

What is the difference between an automatic and a manual car?

The main difference is how the car changes gear. In a manual car, you decide when to change gear using the clutch pedal and gear stick. An automatic car changes gear for you. There is no clutch pedal, so you only use the accelerator and brake while driving.

 AutomaticManual
Changing gearAutomaticYou change gear yourself
Clutch pedalNoYes
Busy city trafficFewer actions requiredRegular gear changes
Getting used to itMay take some adjustmentFamiliar if you normally drive manual
Rental availabilityDepends on location and datesDepends on location and dates

 

When is an automatic rental car a good choice?

An automatic can be a practical choice if you want to spend less time thinking about changing gear. This can be particularly useful when you are driving somewhere unfamiliar.

An automatic rental car may suit you if you expect:

  • Busy city traffic: you do not need to keep changing gear when stopping and starting.
  • Long journeys: there are fewer actions to perform while driving.
  • Unfamiliar roads: you can concentrate more on traffic, directions and your surroundings.
  • To drive an automatic at home: choosing what you already know can make getting into a rental car easier.

If your trip involves plenty of city driving or long distances, an automatic may therefore offer some extra convenience.

When should you choose a manual rental car?

If you normally drive a manual car, renting one may simply feel more familiar. You already know how to operate the car and do not need to adjust to a different way of driving.

A manual rental car may be a good fit if you:

  • Prefer to control when the car changes gear.
  • Usually drive a manual car.
  • Feel more comfortable with a clutch and gear stick.
  • Do not want to change your usual driving habits while travelling.

Practical tip: do not base your decision only on what you drive at home. Think about your destination too. An automatic can be particularly convenient if you expect traffic jams, frequent stop start traffic or hilly roads.

Is an automatic car easier to drive?

For many drivers, an automatic means fewer things to do behind the wheel. You do not need to operate a clutch or decide when to change gear. Whether that makes an automatic easier depends on what you are used to. If you have driven a manual car for years, an automatic may initially feel unfamiliar.

Driving an automatic for the first time? Take a moment before setting off to familiarise yourself with the gear selector and controls. When driving, use only your right foot for both the accelerator and brake pedals.

Automatic or manual for a holiday?

Your destination can make a difference to your choice. On a relaxed road trip along quiet roads, the type of transmission may not matter much. If you expect to spend a lot of time in cities or slow-moving traffic, however, an automatic can reduce the amount of gear changing you need to do.

Distance is worth considering too. If you are planning a road trip with a rental car, think about which option you would feel most comfortable driving for several hours. Travelling abroad? Your transmission is only one thing to consider. Check the local traffic rules and any toll requirements, as well as the rental conditions for taking your vehicle across borders.

What should you consider when choosing a rental car?

Transmission is only one part of choosing the right rental car. The number of passengers, your luggage and the type of journey you are planning can be just as important.

Before booking, ask yourself:

  1. Am I more comfortable driving an automatic or a manual?
  2. Will I mainly be driving in cities or on motorways?
  3. How far am I likely to drive?
  4. How much room do I need for passengers and luggage?
  5. Which vehicles are available for my travel dates?

This helps you choose not just between automatic and manual, but a rental car that suits your trip as a whole.

Can you rent automatic and manual cars with Enterprise?

Enterprise offers a range of vehicle categories. The cars and transmission types available can vary depending on the rental location, vehicle category and dates. If you specifically want an automatic or manual rental car, check the available options when making your reservation.

There is no single right choice for every journey. An automatic can be convenient if you prefer fewer actions behind the wheel, while a manual may be the more familiar option if that is what you usually drive.

Frequently asked questions

Yes. Enterprise offers rental cars with automatic transmissions. Availability varies by location, vehicle category and rental period, so check the available options when making your reservation.

An automatic requires fewer actions while driving because you do not need to use a clutch or change gear yourself. Whether you find it easier will also depend on the type of car you are used to driving.

Yes. If your Dutch category B driving licence allows you to drive a manual passenger car, you can also drive an automatic passenger car.

Yes, an automatic can be a convenient choice for long journeys. It can be particularly useful if your route involves traffic jams, busy roads or frequent stopping and starting.

Use only your right foot for the accelerator and brake, and familiarise yourself with the gear selector before setting off. Take some time at the start of your journey to get used to how the car responds.